IRF Kiruna


Meteoroids 2001

Conference at the

Swedish Institute of Space Physics,

Kiruna, Sweden
6-10 August 2001


[Programme]

Session 2: "The Leonids Meteor Shower"

Date: Monday 14.00-16.05

 

Orbital Perturbations on Dust Trails: Predicting Meteor Storms

David Asher (Armagh Observatory, UK, and Bisei Spaceguard Center, Japan)

Although the chaotic nature of planet-crossing orbits limits the timescale over which their dynamical evolution can be reliably calculated, a sufficiently accurate initial orbit can at least be followed for some time (e.g., centuries) into the future. When debris is released from a comet during a given return to perihelion, the first stage of its evolution is to stretch gradually into a long, dense, narrow trail of meteoroids and dust. Perturbations on particles in the trail are a function of position along the trail, and position along the trail depends almost entirely on orbital period, particles of shorter/longer period being ahead/behind. Therefore perturbations at all points along the trail, and their consequent effect on the trail's location, can be reliably calculated until chaotic behaviour sets in (e.g., for some centuries). Since meteor storms occur when the Earth passes near the centre of a trail, where the particle density is very high, this has allowed storms and outbursts to be predicted with great accuracy in the Leonids and many other streams. 2.1

 

New Type of Radiation of Bright Leonid Meteors above 130 km

Pavel Spurny, Pavel Koten (Astronomical Institute, Academy of Science, Ondrejov Observatory 251 65 Ondrejov, The Czech Republic), Hans Betlem, Klas Jobse and Jaap van't Leven (Dutch Meteor Society, Lederkarper 4, 2318 NB Leiden, The Netherlands)

Precise atmospheric trajectories of very bright Leonid meteors have been determined from the double-station photographic and video observations of Leonid meteors in scope of the ground-based expedition to China during the exceptional so-called "fireball night " of 1998 November 16/17. Whereas beginning heights of photographed meteors are all lower than 130 km, those observed by the all-sky video system or by the even more sensitive LLTV system were recorded up to 200 km for the brightest Leonids meteors. Such high beginnings for meteors have never before been observed. All cases with beginnings recorded by sensitive LLTV systems exhibit comet-like diffuse structures with sizes on the order of kilometers that developed quickly during the meteoroids descent through the atmosphere. For the brightest event with maximum absolute magnitude of -12.5, we observed an arc similar to a solar protuberance and producing a jet detectable several kilometers sideways from the brightest parts of the meteor head, and moving with a velocity over 100 km/s. These jets are common features for all studied very high altitude meteors. When these meteoroids reached 130 km height, their diffuse structures of the radiation quickly transformed to the usual meteor appearance resembling moving droplets, and meteor trains started to develop. Recently we observed similar behavior for two Eta Aquarid, one Perseid and one Lyrid meteors with beginning heights up to 150 km. These meteor phenomena above 130 km were not recognized before our observations, and they cannot be explained by standard ablation theory. 2.2

 

Prediction and Observations of Leonid Meteor Shower in China

Guang-jie Wu (Yunnan Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Kunming 650011, and National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100012) and Guang-yu Li Yue-hua Ma (Purple Mountain Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210008, and National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100012)

Recent years, Leonid meteor shower has been paid more attention in China. Observations by both visible and radio have been performed under the organizing of Chinese Leonid Watch. We have observed some interesting phenomena, like the filamentary structure of the shower, the variations of the size distribution of meteoroids and the mass density. In 1998, Chinese and Dutch astronomers in Qinghai firstly observed an activity of very bright fireballs; in Xinxiang, we observed the expected main shower with radar, and the radio peak was as high as 2500 hr-1; in Yunnan, the records indicated that the contour of the peak maximum is asymmetry. An abnormal peak in the ionosphere characteristic value was also detected about 18 hours after the main shower. In 1999 and 2000, the observations were still obtained greatly. From observed differences between the longitude of the ascending node of meteoroids and that of their parent comet, we find this difference depends on the ejection position as well as the ejection velocity. We successfully predicted the Leonids in 1999 and 2000 with a T_{E-C} versus CEOS diagram. We are working on the research of the orbital evolution of the meteoroid stream with the calculation of celestial mechanics. 2.3

 

Leonid Storm Research in the Near Future

P. Jenniskens (SETI Institute, at NASA Ames Research Center)

Recent observations and dynamical models show that the biggest Leonid storms in this season are still to come. In November of 2001 and 2002, Zenith Hourly Rates are predicted to increase to levels above the storm of 1999. And the next storm is not until 2099. Results from the 1999 Leonid storm research were published, recently, in a special isues of "Earth, Moon and Planets", Meteoritics & Planetary Science, and the Geophysical Research Letters. In this presentation, I will summarize some results from key areas of Leonid storm and meteor outburst research to date, elaborate on how those results further other research fields, and discuss in what areas future research might make rapid progress. PSA-13

 

The Activity Profile of Comet 55P/Tempel-Tuttle in 1998 return: Meteoroid Release Concentration on the Perihelion

J. Watanabe (Nat. Astron. Obs.Japan), H. Fukushima (Nat. Astron. Obs. Japan) and T. Nakamura (Canon Co. Ltd)

It is important to know the activity profile of the parent comets of meteor showers. The activity of the parent comet of the Leonids, 55P/Tempel-Tuttle had never been followed until the recent return in 1998 mainly due to the geometrical difficulty of its orbit relative to the Earth. We carried out a CCD imaging monitor of this comet from January through February in 1998 by using 50-cm telescope of National Astronomical Observatory, Japan. The circular shape of the coma was not changed during this period for the pre-perihelion phase. The photometric measurements of the coma indicated high dependency of the activity on the heliocentric distance, of which the parameter index n is derived as about 10. This large value indicates that the dust release from comet 55P/Tempel-Tuttle is concentrated at around the perihelion passage. PSA-14

 

Theoretical Entry Modeling of Large Leonid Bolides

Douglas O. ReVelle (Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico USA)

We have used the entry model of ReVelle (1979) using an energy of ablation/unit mass for vaporization for weak cometary meteoroids of 3.8 MJ/kg (Jessberger et. al., 1988). These model predictions have been combined with the energetics model of ReVelle (1993). The energetics model has been calibrated using the flight data from the Pribram, Lost City and Innisfree meteorites where ReVelle (1980) determined that at the observed end height about 1 % of the kinetic energy of the original body remained. If the above estimate of the value of the energy of vaporization/kg of cometary meteoroids is reduced by a factor of 5, very good agreement is obtained between the theoretical, equilibrium flow, entry model and the observed ablation parameter (0.10-0.21 kg/MJ, personal communication with P. Spurny, 2000) for large, low density, Leonid meteor-fireballs. Predictions of the expected laminar and turbulent convective heat transfer and of the radiative heat transfer coefficients (regardless of the gas cap opacity) are made using entirely analytic expressions that were developed. These expressions allow a prediction of the velocity, the ablation parameter, the percentage mass loss and of the Knudsen number, etc. to be made. In addition, values of the line source, nonlinear blast wave relaxation radius and of the associated infrasonic wave frequencies are also determined. 2.4

 

Leonid Entry Modeling: Application to the Bolide of November 17, 1999

Douglas O. ReVelle (Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico USA)

The results of ReVelle (AIAA Aerospace Sciences Conference, Reno, Nevada, January, 2000) are compared against atmospheric observations of the Leonid fireball of 11/17/1999 in northern New Mexico (NM). These included observations at the Phillips Laboratory Starfire Optical Range (USAF facility) near Albuquerque of the so-called "glow-worm" persistent train which could be tracked for ~1 hour, intensified CCD camera records at Placitas, NM, by all-sky video camera records and infrared radiometers at Sandia National Laboartory in Albuquerque as well as by 2 ground observers in the town of Los Alamos. This bolide was also detected infrasonically at Los Alamos National Laboratory at the CTBT, IMS (Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, International Monitoring System) prototype array by ReVelle and Whitaker (Meteoritics, 2000). We compare model predictions of velocity, mass, blast wave radius, wave frequency, etc. as a function of the initial source energy against the results predicted using the infrasonic wave arrivals and their properties at the ground (amplitude, wave period, duration, etc.) at the observed slant-range from the bolide. The infrasonic signals were analyzed using the basic line source model of ReVelle (1976) and were independently shown to have emanated from a height region near the Mesopause where the bolide explosively ended its visible flight, presumably due to its low material strength. PSA-15

 

Radioseismology as a New Method of Investigations of Meteor Streams on the Moon and Planets

A.A. Berezhnoi (1), E. Bervalds (2), O.B. Khavroshkin (3) and G. Ozolins (2).

(1) Sternberg Astronomical Institute, Moscow, Russia, (2) Ventspils International Radio Astronomy Center, Riga, Latvia, (3) Institute of Earth Physics, Moscow, Russia

Radioseismology is based on registration and interpretation of radio emission of seismic origin. Such radioseismic processes occur on the Moon, planets, and asteroids. Non-thermal radio emission of the Moon caused by rock fracturing, seismic activity, and thermal cracking of the regolith was detected during observations of the Moon at the 64 m Kaliazin radio telescope at 13 and 21 cm on July 31, 1999. We observed the Moon on November 16 - 18, 2000 with the 32 m Ventspils antenna at 25 mm. During the morning of November 17 we registered significant quasiperiodic oscillations of the lunar radio emission starting near 1:44 UT and contining until the end of observations at 7:17 UT. Oscillations were also registered on November 18 starting near 2:28 UT. Intensive oscillations were registered until about 7:00 UT with bottom to peak heights of 5-10 K. The time of maxima of oscillations does not contradict theoretical predictions about the existence of three maxima of the Leonid meteor shower on the Moon. Amplitudes of oscillations were equal to 1-2 K before and after the time of Leonid's maxima. These results can be explained as the detection of lunar radio emission of seismic origin caused by meteoroid impacts. The implications of the radioseismic method for determination of the intensity of meteor showers on the Moon and planets and the internal structure of the Moon are described. PSA-16

 

The Global Monitor of Meteor Streams by Radio Meteor Observation

Hiroshi Ogawa, Shinji Toyomasu, Kimio Maegawa and Koji Ohnishi

In recent years, in Japan, Radio Meteor Observation(RMO) has spreads, and RMO has come to be observed by many observers. Then, to grasp the whole aspect of meteor stream activity accurately, the necessity of unifying the observational data all over the world came out. Then, we tried to correct and integrate them. To consider the error by geographical factor or the observational equipment, the data was divided by average counts previous one week. The 2000 Leonids RMO result at eight sites of the world was unified by this method, and three peaks appeared. This is similar to the result of Visual Observation. In this time, however, it was considered without using the radar equation etc, we could get result as almost same as Visual Observation. Therefore, the more exact result could be obtained if we consider of it. However, it cannot unify easily now, because we have poor information on the various equipment and various geographical conditions. It cannot unify easily at a present stage. Consequently I would like to collect the detailed data of each observational site, and to establish the method of catching meteor stream activity accurately. PSA-17

 

The Result of 1999 Leonids Daytime Observation in Japan

Hirotaka Serizawa and Masayuki Toda

The large appearance of Leonids was observed in Europe on November 18 in 1999 at the 2:00UT (11:00JST). Then, daytime-meteor was detected some observers in each place, and the number of 40 meteors were detected in 4 hours in Japan. Since globally daytime-meteor observation is rare most people would have doubt about the objectivity of data. Therefore, I tried to identify with each Radio Meteor Observation, in order to acquire the objectivity of data. Consequently, four shooting stars were in accorded with the result of Radio Meteor Observation. Besides, two synchronous meteors were observed by two observers. Therefore, these meteors could be reliable. However, there were few bright (shooting stars>-5 magnitude) which could be observed in Europe in daytime at the same time. For that reason, the question arose in the luminous intensity of the meteor that we observed. As one of this cause, it can be considered that the meteor luminescence mechanisms differ daytime from night. I would like to call more observers all over the world to carry on meteor observation from now on to collect the data about a daytime-meteor. PSA-18

 

Ground-based Observations of the Leonids 1999-2000

M.D. Campbell, C. Theijsmeijer, J. Jones (University of Western Ontario, London, ON, N6A 3K7 Canada), R.L. Hawkes (Mount Allison University, Sackville, NB, E4L 1E6 Canada) and P. Brown (Los Alamos National Laboratories Los Alamos, NM 87545 USA)

We present video observations of the 1999 Leonid shower made from Israel and similar observations collected in Spain and New Mexico for the 2000 shower. During the 1999 Leonid storm a total of 233 double-station Leonids were recorded. The mean begin, maximum brightness and end heights are 123.3 ± 0.7 km, 107.3 ± 0.42 km and 95.0 ± 0.56 km respectively for storm Leonids of average mass ~10-6 - 10-7 kg. The peak flux at the time of the 1999 storm was found to be 0.81 ± 0.06 meteoroids km-2 hour-1 brighter than +6.5. using 15 minute binning and 0.99 ± 0.11 meteoroids km-2 hour-1 brighter than +6.5 for 3 minute intervals. The smaller temporal resolution reveals a broad plateau in flux lasting from approximately solar longitude=235.276° - 235.285° (J2000.0). The video mass distribution index over the course of the Leonid storm was found to be constant constant near s=1.75 and near s=1.7 in 2000. The peak time of the storm estimated from 3 minute resolution video counts place the maximum at 235.281°±0.003° (1h55m ± 4m). We do not find evidence for any significant high altitude Leonid population in 1999 at video masses despite biasing one camera pair to an intersection altitude of 160 km. The 2000 shower showed two distinct peaks separated by 24 hours. We recorded a peak video flux of 0.06 meteoroids km-2 hour-1 brighter than +6.5 near solar longitude=236.15° during the 2000 Leonids. We also discuss preliminary radar observations in 2000 which suggests that an earlier peak near solar longitude=235.29 ± 0.02 is much stronger than reported by visual observations and dominates the later visual peak at 236.25 ± 0.02. PSA-19

 

Video Spectra of Leonids and Other Meteors

Jiri Borovicka (Astronomical Institute, Academy of Sciences, 251 65 Ondrejov, Czech Republic)

More than thousand Leonid video spectra were obtained during the expeditions in the years 1998-2000. A survey of the spectra with the emphasis to the effect of early release of sodium will be presented. Leonid spectra will be compared to the spectra of other meteor showers obtained with the same instrument at the Ondrejov Observatory. PSA-20

 

On Periodic Activity Variations during the 1999 Leonid Meteor Storm in Various Data Sets

Jurgen Rendtel (International Meteor Organization, Potsdam, Germany).

Observational data obtained during the 1999 Leonid meteor storm using intensified video cameras as well as meteor radar systems showed significant fluctuations of the activity. Applying a wavelet analysis to the data it is shown that we see quasi-periodic variations with a typical period of 7 minutes. Given the geocentric velocity of the Leonid meteoroids, this hints at structures within the stream at a scale of about 30000 km along the Earth's passage, or about 9000 km vertical to the stream's plane. As the distance between the observing sites at which such fluctuations were recorded is of the order of several 1000 km in N-S and E-W direction, the variations should reflect a characteristic of the stream. Similar observations are only possible during meteor storms in order to collect a sufficient sample within 2 minutes or less. 2.5

 

The Leonid Meteors Found in Chinese Historical Records

Y. Fujiwara (Nippon Meteor Society)

Beijin Observatory published the compilation of the Chinese historical records of meteor showers and individual fireballs. Since some records of the fireballs indicate the meteor trail with Chinese constellation or bright fixed stars and the directions of the path, we can estimate probable path of the meteor. So we can identify the permanent shower meteor not only the aid of the solar longitude at the meteor apparition but also the its path. In this paper some Leonid meteor records found in Chinese chronicles by using this method are presented. PSA-21

 

Spectroscopic Analysis of Fine Structures in Leonids

Toshio Tsukamoto (Nagoya university), Shinsuke Abe (Institute of Space and Astronautical Science), Noboru Ebizuka (The Institute of Physical and Chemical Research), Hajime Yano (Institute of Space and Astronautical Science), Yasuhiro Hirahara (Nagoya university) and Jun-ichi Watanabe (National Astronomical Observatory)

Observations of meteors and the orbital caluculations lead to understanding behavior of cometary dust grains in space. Spectroscopic obserations of meteors enable us to investigate not only the chemical composition of meteors but also the chemical heterogeniety among the meteor dust trails (fine structures) . However, there had not been enough data to understand fine structures in a meteor shower until the 1999 Leonids. 55P/Tempel-Tuttle, the parent comet of the Leonid stream, returns to perihelion every 33 years, generating a new trail of dust each time. During the 1999 Leonid meteor storm, the Earth encountered various trails which allowed us to study the fine structure between those dust trails generated in different perihelion epochs. We report results of those fine structures within the 1999 Leonids. These observations were carried out using Grism as slitless spectrometer with an image intensifier. The images were recorded on NTSC video at a rate of 30 frames per second, with 37.1 $B!_ (B20.8 deg, FOV. The main peak occurred around 2hUT while sub-peaks stood out around 1h30m, 1h45m, 2h15m, 2h20m, 3h00m UT on 18 November 1999. We examine the temporal spectroscopic differences among those fine structures. PSA-22

 

Persistent Leonid Meteor Trails: Types I and II

J.D. Drummond, S. Milster, B. W. Grime, D. Barnaby (Air Force Research Laboratory), C. S. Gardner, A. Z. Liu, X. Chu (University of Illinois), M. C. Kelley, C. Kruschwitz (Cornell University) and T. J. Kane (Pennsylvania State University)

From our 1998 and 1999 study of Leonid lingering trails, we have identified two types of trails. Type I trails are wide (1 km after a minute) with high diffusion rates (1000 m^2/sec), appear turbid, optically thick, and 'puffy'. Type II trails are narrow (< 100 m), often parallel, with low diffusion rates (10 m^2/sec), appearing optically thin, smooth, and clean. Of the four trails extensively studied, one is Type I only, another is Type II only, and two show both types of trails. Information (especially altitude) from a sodium lidar is used to derive detailed geometric parameters for the trails. For example, diffusion appears to be a function of altitude, with the hyperbolic tangent function describing the transition from low to high rates. A 17 minute video will be shown, and line emission rates, diffusion coefficients, and other data will be given for each. PSA-23

 

Fine Structures within the Leonid Dust Trail: Resonant Filament Model Examined by Optical Video Observations

Hajime Yano (Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, Japan), Shinsuke Abe (Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, Japan) Noboru Ebizuka (The Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, Japan) Norimoto Fujino (Science University of Tokyo, Japan) and Jun-ichi Watanabe (National Astronomical Observatory, Japan)

We observed the Leonid meteor showers by real-time video imagery of high definition digital video cameras with image intensifiers (HDTV-II) onboard airborne platforms (Leonid MAC) in 1998 (over the Pacific)-1999 (over the Mediterranean), and NTSC digital video CCD cameras (WATEC) placed at a 2500-m class mountain in the Canary Islands in 2000. HDTV-II and NTSC videos had different limiting magnitudes for meteor detection (e.g., the 8th mag. for HDTV-II with a f1.0 50-mm lens) but both indicated fine structures (in several to a few tens of minutes) of the flux variation within each main peak. Such trends became more evident as the magnitudes of observed Leonids went fainter. Recently Cevolani and Pupilo reported radio observations of the 1999 Leonids from Italian ground stations also found the same as our results. These temporal flux variations seemed to coincide with periods that the Earth crossed the $B!H (Binhomogeneous $B!I (B Leonid dust trail, which is composed of the smoothed $B!H (Bbackground $B!I (B component and several narrow, $B!H (Bdust filaments $B!I (B ejected from the parent comet P/Tempel-Tuttle in the last several perihelion passages. Thus, our results directly confirm the resonant cometary dust trail model proposed by McNaught and Asher in 1999, especially in the smaller end of the Leonids. PSA-24

 

Five-year Cooperative Radio Observations of the Leonid Meteoroid Stream by the BLM Radar System

V.Porubcan (1), A.Hajduk (1), G. Cevolani (2) and G. Pupillo (2).

(1) Astronomical Institute, Slovak Academy of Sciences, 84228 Bratislava, Slovakia, (2) Istituto ISAO-CNR, via Gobetti 101, 40129 Bologna, Italia

A survey of results from joint campaigns of the Leonid meteoroid stream observed by the BLM (Bologna-Lecce-Modra) forward scatter system in 1996-2000 is presented. The Leonid radio observations were carried out on November 10-20, each year along two baselines: Bologna-Lecce (Italy) and Bologna-Modra (Slovakia). Trends of long duration echoes and variations of reflection time exhibit a multiple peak activity which is possibly connected with a filamentary structure of the Leonid meteoroid stream. The mass distribution exponents of the Leonid meteoroids in the period of the shower peak activity show significant changes throughout the 5-year observational period, with a higher representation of larger particles mainly in 1998 and 2000, and of relatively smaller particles during the minor meteor storm in 1999. The multiple peak activity and variations of mass exponent in the observed period resulting from forward scatter observations are consistent with the results obtained by other techniques. 2.6

 

Radar Observations of the 1999 and 2000 Leonid Meteor Storms at Middle Europe and Northern Scandinavia

Werner Singer (1), Nicholas J. Mitchell (2) and Johannes Weiss (1)

1) Leibniz-Institut fuer Atmosphaerenphysik, 18225 Kuehlungsborn, Germany; 2) Department of Physics, University of Wales, Ceredigion SY23 3BZ, UK

Observations of the 1999 and 2000 Leonid meteor storms made with all-sky meteor radars in Middle Europe (54N) and northern Scandinavia (68N) were analyzed in terms of height-dependend meteor rates and entrance velocities. The 1999 Leonid meteor storm is characterised by a major activity peak on November 18 at 2h5m UT with a peak rate of about 1400 meteors/h. In contrast to the 1999 observations, we found three activity maxima for the 2000 Leonid storm. The first peak (170 meteors/h) was observed on November 17, 2000, at 8h15m UT related with the 1932 Leonid dust trail. The second well pronounced maximum (130 meteors/h) was detected on november 18 at 7h25m UT associated with the 1866 Leonid dust trail. The third broad activity event (about 70 meteors/h on average) was found on November 18 between 1h UT and 5h UT related with the 1733 Leonid dust trail. During both years the Leonid storm activity was dominant at altitudes above 98 km. PSA-25

 

Meteor observations from Israel

Noah Brosch (Wise Observatory, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel)

We observed meteors of the Leonid and other showers with an L-band radar system. In the case of the 1999 Leonids we detected a twin-peaked dheight distribution, where the surprising finding was of a wide peak centered near 250-km altitude. We present a possible mechanism to generate radar returns at such heights. We also describe the development status of a two-station system to observe video meteors, which is planned to operate in the second half of 2001. 2.7

 

Observations on Stratospheric-Mesospheric-Thermospheric Temperatures Using Indian MST Radar and Co-located LIDAR during Leonid Meteor Shower (LMS)

R. Selvamurugan (1) , C.V. Devasia (2), A.R. Jain (1), C. Raghava Reddi (2).P.B. Rao (1) and R. Sridharan (2)

1) National MST Radar Facility, Tirupati, 517 502, India; 2)Space Physics Laboratory, Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre, Trivandrum 695 022, India

The temporal and height statistics of the occurrence of meteor trails during the Leonid meteor shower revealed the capability of the Indian MST radar to record large number of meteor trails. The distribution of Radio meteor trails due to Leonid meteor shower in space and time provided a unique opportunity to construct the height profiles of lower thermospheric temperatures and winds with good time and height resolution. There was a four-fold increase in the meteor trails observed during the LMS compared to a typical non-shower day. The temperatures were found to be in excellent continuity with the temperature profiles below the radio meteor region derived from the co-located Nd-Yag LIDAR and extend the maximum height of the temperature profile from the LIDAR to ~110 km. There are however some significant differences between the observed profiles and the CIRA-86 model profiles. The first results on the meteor statistics and neutral temperature are presented and discussed below. PSA-26


[Programme]

Page maintained by webmaster@irf.se
Latest update: 29 June 2001